Geek Feminism Wiki
Register
m (→‎Women and friends: fix formatting)
 
(12 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
  +
This page lists patterns and anti-patterns that you may want to incorporate/avoid when creating a [[Feminist and women's hackerspaces|feminist hackerspace]].
 
=Patterns=
 
=Patterns=
   
Line 7: Line 8:
 
Feminism acknowledges structural oppression exists in society now. Creating a space with less oppression requires borders between the space and society at large. Access to the community - both its physical space and online community - needs to be controlled.
 
Feminism acknowledges structural oppression exists in society now. Creating a space with less oppression requires borders between the space and society at large. Access to the community - both its physical space and online community - needs to be controlled.
   
Physical security: multiple levels of physical security are good. Don't have a door that opens directly to the street. Your space will need to balance how easily it wants visitors to find it with how private you want it to be. 
+
Physical security: multiple levels of physical security are good. Don't have a door that opens directly to the street.
   
 
==Safe neighborhood==
 
==Safe neighborhood==
  +
"Safe" can be a racist and classist evaluation of a neighborhood where many people work and live.  It is a better pattern to become familiar with a neighborhood than to think of some neighborhoods as "safe" and some not. It is also important to consider who you are speaking about a neighborhood as being "safe" for. In short it is very misleading term.
   
Use crime maps to evaluate, not just neighborhood reputation. Narcotics arrests are a good proxy for street harassment of women.
+
For visiting neighborhoods unfamiliar to you, use crime maps to evaluate activity patterns. Narcotics arrests are a good proxy for street harassment of women. Public transit corridors may have a high volume of night time arrests but give the protection of many people being around at night.
   
 
==Transit==
 
==Transit==
   
Public transit, parking, bike lanes and parking, and walking. Consider where the public transit routes come from; if they primarily come from white or affluent areas, white and affluent people will find it easier to take transit to your space. 
+
Public transit, parking, bike lanes and parking, and walking.
   
 
==Accessibility==
 
==Accessibility==
   
 
Elevator, bathroom. Full ADA accessibility is not always easy to find at a price you can afford but often you can get pretty close by negotiating with the landlord for extra keys, small remodels, etc.
 
Elevator, bathroom. Full ADA accessibility is not always easy to find at a price you can afford but often you can get pretty close by negotiating with the landlord for extra keys, small remodels, etc.
  +
  +
Design your space and events so that it can be negotiated by a person in a wheelchair. It is good to design for furniture to be moveable and people's personal belongings to be up off the floor.
  +
  +
Here are some thoughts on accessibility of various kinds, not limited to physical access and wheelchairs: http://www.wiscon.info/access.php
   
 
==Women-only==
 
==Women-only==
Line 27: Line 33:
 
Pros:
 
Pros:
   
It is often difficult to create and sustain a women-centered organization when people of other genders are included, in particular because many of us are socialized from birth to pay more attention to and value (white) men's voices over everyone else's. Not having men as members prevents
+
It is often difficult to create and sustain a women-centered organization when people of other genders are included, in particular because many of us are socialized from birth to pay more attention to and value (white) men's voices over everyone else's.
   
 
Cons:
 
Cons:
   
Often geeky women have little experience with women-only spaces that are welcoming for them and assume a women-only space would be similarly uncomfortable. This may be in part because it is difficult to experience an in-person women-only group of women with similar interests if you are geeky due to the low density of geek women in many geographical areas. Whether or not your group decides that transgender men are welcome, someone will feel hurt or excluded. It can be more difficult to fund a women-only space, particularly if few of your members work in the technology field, due to women tending to be paid less than men.
+
Often geeky women have little experience with women-only spaces that are welcoming for them and assume a women-only space would be similarly uncomfortable. This may be in part because it is difficult to experience an in-person women-only group of women with similar interests if you are geeky due to the low density of geek women in many geographical areas. It can be more difficult to fund a women-only space, particularly if few of your members work in the technology field, due to women tending to be paid less than men.
   
 
Examples:
 
Examples:
   
[http://www.doubleunion.org/membership Double Union]
+
* [http://www.doubleunion.org/membership Double Union]
   
 
==Women and friends==
 
==Women and friends==
   
The space is designed as women-centered, but people of all genders are welcome as members. The space leadership (board and officers) may or may not be all women. 
+
The space is designed as women-centered, but people of all genders are welcome as members. The space leadership (board and officers) should be mostly or entirely women. 
   
 
Examples:
 
Examples:
Line 51: Line 57:
   
 
==Fiscal sponsorship==
 
==Fiscal sponsorship==
  +
 
Fiscal sponsorship is an arrangement where your organization gains 501c3 status via the fiscal sponsor in exchange for a percentage of the donations that are routed through the fiscal sponsor (usually 7-10%). Ask around for recommendations--not all fiscal sponsors are good partners, and some cannot offer sufficient financial transparency.
 
Fiscal sponsorship is an arrangement where your organization gains 501c3 status via the fiscal sponsor in exchange for a percentage of the donations that are routed through the fiscal sponsor (usually 7-10%). Ask around for recommendations--not all fiscal sponsors are good partners, and some cannot offer sufficient financial transparency.
  +
  +
If you are a non-profit, philanthropic corporations such as Microsoft may match individual donations made by their employees. Some corporations may be willing to commit to matching donations from the general public under certain conditions (eg "up to $2000 of donations made today").
   
 
==Community assets==
 
==Community assets==
   
From the very beginning, don't put community infrastructure on personal computer accounts. Share passwords between at least 3 people.
+
From the very beginning, don't put community infrastructure on personal computer accounts. Share passwords between at least 3 people and set account emails (eg, Twitter's email for you, your webhost's email for you) to go to a group of people.
   
 
==Leave the space clean==
 
==Leave the space clean==
Line 70: Line 79:
   
 
==It's okay to not be friends with everyone==
 
==It's okay to not be friends with everyone==
  +
  +
== Base assumptions and points of unity ==
  +
At the outset, define values you can assume other members strive for and specify what isn't ok. It is best to do this even before a public call for members and volunteers.
   
 
=Anti-patterns=
 
=Anti-patterns=
  +
  +
==Transitive trust==
  +
Trust is not always transitive. Your nice friend or co-worker who you know is being ironic or has a particular behavior quirk can be someone else's somewhat creepy stranger. Friends of friends can't get an automatic pass to a hackerspace; their behavior has to stand well on its own.
  +
==Everyone help me start!==
  +
A hackerspace that opens a public call for volunteers early risks getting caught up in extensive fighting about ground rules, such as whether to identify the space as feminist, whether to be women-members-only or not, or what basic policies to have in place.
  +
  +
Settle basic non-negotiable properties of the community in a small aligned founders group before opening public calls for volunteers. When making public calls for volunteers or members, advertise your non-negotiable ground rules.
   
 
==Feminist hackerspaces as finishing schools==
 
==Feminist hackerspaces as finishing schools==
Line 90: Line 109:
   
 
==Requiring mind-reading==
 
==Requiring mind-reading==
  +
[[Category:Community management]]
  +
[[Category:Design patterns]]

Latest revision as of 00:34, 15 July 2014

This page lists patterns and anti-patterns that you may want to incorporate/avoid when creating a feminist hackerspace.

Patterns

For general hackerspace design patterns, see the Hackerspaces.org design patterns.

Borders

Feminism acknowledges structural oppression exists in society now. Creating a space with less oppression requires borders between the space and society at large. Access to the community - both its physical space and online community - needs to be controlled.

Physical security: multiple levels of physical security are good. Don't have a door that opens directly to the street.

Safe neighborhood

"Safe" can be a racist and classist evaluation of a neighborhood where many people work and live.  It is a better pattern to become familiar with a neighborhood than to think of some neighborhoods as "safe" and some not. It is also important to consider who you are speaking about a neighborhood as being "safe" for. In short it is very misleading term.

For visiting neighborhoods unfamiliar to you, use crime maps to evaluate activity patterns. Narcotics arrests are a good proxy for street harassment of women. Public transit corridors may have a high volume of night time arrests but give the protection of many people being around at night.

Transit

Public transit, parking, bike lanes and parking, and walking.

Accessibility

Elevator, bathroom. Full ADA accessibility is not always easy to find at a price you can afford but often you can get pretty close by negotiating with the landlord for extra keys, small remodels, etc.

Design your space and events so that it can be negotiated by a person in a wheelchair. It is good to design for furniture to be moveable and people's personal belongings to be up off the floor.

Here are some thoughts on accessibility of various kinds, not limited to physical access and wheelchairs: http://www.wiscon.info/access.php

Women-only

Only women can be members of the hackerspace. People of other genders and ages may or may not be welcome as guests.

Pros:

It is often difficult to create and sustain a women-centered organization when people of other genders are included, in particular because many of us are socialized from birth to pay more attention to and value (white) men's voices over everyone else's.

Cons:

Often geeky women have little experience with women-only spaces that are welcoming for them and assume a women-only space would be similarly uncomfortable. This may be in part because it is difficult to experience an in-person women-only group of women with similar interests if you are geeky due to the low density of geek women in many geographical areas. It can be more difficult to fund a women-only space, particularly if few of your members work in the technology field, due to women tending to be paid less than men.

Examples:

Women and friends

The space is designed as women-centered, but people of all genders are welcome as members. The space leadership (board and officers) should be mostly or entirely women. 

Examples:

Crowd funding

Successful campaigns launch on a Monday or Tuesday. 

Fiscal sponsorship

Fiscal sponsorship is an arrangement where your organization gains 501c3 status via the fiscal sponsor in exchange for a percentage of the donations that are routed through the fiscal sponsor (usually 7-10%). Ask around for recommendations--not all fiscal sponsors are good partners, and some cannot offer sufficient financial transparency.

If you are a non-profit, philanthropic corporations such as Microsoft may match individual donations made by their employees. Some corporations may be willing to commit to matching donations from the general public under certain conditions (eg "up to $2000 of donations made today").

Community assets

From the very beginning, don't put community infrastructure on personal computer accounts. Share passwords between at least 3 people and set account emails (eg, Twitter's email for you, your webhost's email for you) to go to a group of people.

Leave the space clean

Establish strong community norms of always cleaning up after yourselves before leaving the space. Exceptions for long-running projects need to be made clearly and with specific rules. The space should make cleaning intuitive: clearly labeled trash, recycling, dish storage, where to wash.

Clutter is an accessiblity issue.

Pseudonymity

Make rules explicit

Enforced anti-harassment policy

It's okay to not be friends with everyone

Base assumptions and points of unity

At the outset, define values you can assume other members strive for and specify what isn't ok. It is best to do this even before a public call for members and volunteers.

Anti-patterns

Transitive trust

Trust is not always transitive. Your nice friend or co-worker who you know is being ironic or has a particular behavior quirk can be someone else's somewhat creepy stranger. Friends of friends can't get an automatic pass to a hackerspace; their behavior has to stand well on its own.

Everyone help me start!

A hackerspace that opens a public call for volunteers early risks getting caught up in extensive fighting about ground rules, such as whether to identify the space as feminist, whether to be women-members-only or not, or what basic policies to have in place.

Settle basic non-negotiable properties of the community in a small aligned founders group before opening public calls for volunteers. When making public calls for volunteers or members, advertise your non-negotiable ground rules.

Feminist hackerspaces as finishing schools

Highlander

Queen bee

Too open

Stamp of approval

Gatekeeping

Over-processing

Keeping everyone happy

Requiring mind-reading